granma earwen was tiny? but galady and her bros are tol that means finarfin must have been GIANT

tosquinha:

I don’t think GIANT defines him, just as tall as his kids I guess? And short Earwen admitedly comes out of nowhere but my own nonsense wishes (weirdly enough, sinceTelerin and Sindar are some of the tallest elves to me) so just bear with me here.I freely  admit I follow kinda loose genetics rules a with these elves ha 

Anyway since you asked, a long post to follow how I’ve been headcanoning this lineage for a long while, until we get to tall Arwen who began the discussion.