*blushes* Thankies š
Tag: Anonymous
Dets! Did you know that Tolkien planned that his books would be a springboard for people to build on and broaden the scope of Middle Earth. Which is exactly what Sansukh has done!!! Good job keeping Tolkien alive.
I had heard/read somewhere that the Prof wished for people to build on his foundation and continue to grow his universe, but omg I hadnāt actually⦠connected it⦠to fanfictionā¦

I love the new song! I mean, I love all the sons, but I’m really digging the new one! <3

THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU SO MUCH! that means the world to me, I am absolutely thrilled you like it!
I always have a really hard time starting new writing projects, any advice for writer’s block/how to start?
oh cripes, I am bad at advice, ask anyone.Ā
Thereās a lot of writing blogs out there with good ideas for starting! All I have is this: if thereās one particular scene you really want to write, but you have to slog through a whole bunch of connecting scenes/chapters to get to it? WRITE THE ONE YOU WANT TO WRITE FIRST. The TARGET scene.
It usually gives me ideas on how to approach it, ways in which to complicate that approach, etc. By the time Iāve filled in the intermediate steps, I have an even better idea of how that original target scene could go, and even more meaty stuff to pack into it.Ā
Thatās all I got, Nonnie. Sorry I am a bit useless at this!
Wouldn’t Durin VII have priority over the throne to DĆsith, because he’s male? Or does little DĆs have priority because she’s first born…? The line of Durin only mentions Kings- Is that just because males are so much more common in dwarves? *~*
The Line of Durin only mentions Kings because Tolkien made it that way. He also made it so that the Dwarves apparently donāt record the names of the ladies. I expect he probably did think that male primogeniture was the way to go as well. Ā
I dislike this intensely. So Iām changing it. Because fanfiction. So yes, in Sansukh,
DĆsith
is firstborn, so sheās first in line. Durin is not.Ā
(before someone points out
DĆs-the-elder, in Sansukh she abdicated her place in the succession in order to marry Vili – as a lowborn nobody of a miner, he really was at the bottom of the heap. Itās mentioned several times in the fic. Thatās why she didnāt become Queen. Also, she bloody didnāt want it after what it had done to her family.)
Your comment about composers who are hard to sing reminds me of my conductor (he composes/arranges most of our material). We’ll go over a particularly crunchy chord or strange passage and he’ll look down at the music and go “who even wrote that” before chuckling to himself because he’s a dork š
*lies facedown* yeah, I did quite a bit of that, recording this song. I am right there with him. WHO WROTE THIS MONSTROSITY, doesnāt she know we need to BREATHE? what the hell, why why why are there all these tone crunches everywhere, and ow this Sop I part never comes down out of the rafters OW
(Iāve finished recording it now, thankfully! Iāve just got some mastering to go. It is pretty tight harmony,so I want to get the balance right in places, plus there was some annoying popping on the recording of the Alto II part. All cleaned up and pretty now!)
I have to thank you for changing my perception on dwarrows that when I read the phrase”the gold lust of dwarves”(or something similar), whereas in the past I would not feel a thing about it but now I would cringe so much that I feel like I am being insulted personally.
Itās something that offends me too, on a number of levels. So, youāre welcome Nonnie – and Iāll strive to always keep working at dismantling and refuting that stereotype, bc it is bleh. It reminds me of racist invective, and its real-world connotations are antisemitic and just. *brrr* nope.Ā
You are made of stardust and galaxies and I love you. (āæā āæā )
AWWWWWWW KJHSDGSJLHDGAJ THANK YOU

So I don’t know a whole lot about the Durin reincarnation shindig, what’s the deal? How do they know baby Durin is Durin? Explain me a thing please?
Hey Nonnie!
Well, canonically we donāt actually know very much about this. What we have is briefly summarised here. Thereās also the speculation that Durin would return to herald the final era of glory for the Dwarves, before they dwindled and disappeared to give way to the era of Men.Ā
Durin VII is supposed to reclaim Khazad-dum, too š
So, the legend goes like this, in short:Ā
The Dwarves believe that the eldest of the seven original Dwarves, Durin, would be reincarnated seven times and reign as King. There have been six Kings called Durin thus far.Ā
In Sansukh, the seventh just arrived!
We know that Durin VII is meant to be descended from Thorin III Stonehelm, which is shown in the family tree in the LOTR Appendices.Ā

What we DONāT know: how the heck do they know itās Durin??????
My solution: Durinās eyes. They shine in certain light, like ithildin.
Some speculation and ideas, now: I donāt believe that this little baby is going to have ALL the memories of his earlier lives. I think that is a recipe for disaster and heartache, frankly. Heās still a child, who does child things.Ā
Each incarnation is like a possibility: Iām of the nurture-over-nature school of thought here. Depending on the influences in a kidās life they can grow and develop in a myriad of ways, and this one is no different.
Some memories will come later in his life, as he becomes ready for them (not his deaths, though. Mahal would never be so cruel). More important is how people help and prepare him to face his own legend – and whether they treat him like an actual child, who does child-things both good and bad!Ā
His new parents are very well suited to help with this, actually. Thorin Stonehelm knows ALLLLL about following in the footsteps of giants and having to live up to an impossible legacy. And Bomfris would tell Eru himself to shove it where the sun shineth not! Sheās not going to hold back from telling a naughty Durin toĀ āgo to your room!ā if needed.Ā
So, thereās some headcanoning! I hope you like, Nonnie!
im not sure if it’s been mentioned yet, but sam in chapter 46 was a GIFT. so snarky, so brave, so wonderful. im all wibbly, i love him. (also: thorin being referred to as a raincloud is one of my fave things ever)
<3333333 Sam is my Lion of the Shire, I adore him forever.
(that especially snarky line? the āCalling your Chief Names, Wishing to punch his Pimply Face, and Thinking you Shirriffs look a lot of Tom-foolsā line? ISNāT MINE. Thatās Tolkienās, from the chapter The Scouring of the Shire, and is a contender for my favourite line in the whole trilogy. DAMN I LOVE SAM)
heheheheheh, lil Stormcloud, thundering away!Ā
Thank you so so much, Nonnie! *hugs*