I still maintain that anyone who argues whether Frodo or Sam was the “true hero” of the story is entirely missing the point of the whole book
like honestly LOTR is about teamwork and the idea that no one is an island
No part of the quest would have worked without everyone doing their part. that’s a major point about Gollum. Gandalf says, “My heart tells me that he has some part to play yet, for good or ill, before the end; and when that comes, the pity of Bilbo may rule the fate of many – yours not least.”
and this quote from Sauron Defeated, which if you’re not familiar is from the Histories (in this case essentially a draft):
“There’s never only one hero in any true tale, Sam, and all the good folk are in others’ debt. But if one had to choose one and only, I’d choose Samwise.”
“Then you’d be wrong, Mr. Frodo,” said Sam. “For without you I’m nothing. But you and me together, Mr. Frodo: well, that’s more than either alone.”that didn’t make it into the final draft, but that’s still it. “And Frodo wouldn’t have got far without Sam, would he, dad?” No he wouldn’t have, and without Frodo there’d have been nobody to carry the Ring, and without the rest of the Company Frodo couldn’t have got as far as he did nor could Sam have, and without Elrond…well, you get the picture. Everything that happens in the Lord of the Rings is a team effort.
There isn’t one single hero because you don’t save the world by yourself, as a Hero, you do it with other people because nobody can do that by themselves. There’s too much. We need each other, and that’s important.
Tag: frodo baggins
Merry and Pippin and Sam’s kids have so many cool dwarf toys. So many. (They especially like the ones of their dads)
AWWW
tbh, I get the feeling that Frodo would make sure that the little figurine of Samwise the Brave, Mayor of the Shire and hero of Middle-Earth, would be the most popular throughout the entirety of the four farthings…
Courtesy of the Gimizh & co., Gimli and the remainder of the company send a package to Bilbo and the hobbits of the Fellowship. In it? A set of fake beards and mustaches for them, all in the correct colors, made by Dori, Dis, and even one made by Wee Thorin, since, “They don’t got no hair on their faces at all!” Merry and Pippin often wear theirs, especially when they finally *visit* Erebor. Bilbo and Frodo’s *might* make their across the sea with them.
Sam: “Well, look at me, Mister Frodo! Why, I could be as Stoorish as a Breelander!” It gets Frodo to smile. That means it’s worth its weight in gold, as far as Sam’s concerned.
(Tiny little Elanor finds it one day. She looks HYSTERICALLY FUNNY in it.)
Merry & Pippin: *die of laughter, use them to prank each other and everybody else*
Frodo: sends a very polite ‘thank you’ letter… and never wears it.
Bilbo: secretly tries it on in the mirror when nobody else is watching, checks himself from all angles, preens and prances about a bit and chuckles and uses all the Dwarvish swear-words he remembers… and then grows quiet, letting the funny beard fall to his knees and sighing.
After the Quest is over, Bofur makes a killing on hobbit costumes. There are so many babbuhs in Erebor and Dale and, really, all of Middle Earth, dressed up as Frodo and Sam and Pippin and Merry. (Gimizh is not sure which of the hobbits is is favorite, although he, of course, always plays his Brave Uncle Gimli when he and the others recreate the Quest. He once tried to recruit Laerophen to play Legolas.)
Gimizh is of course the envy of every Dwarfling in the North… because he owns the real actual helm that his uncle wore on the Quest.
Wee Thorin is allowed to touch it. Balinith is too.
(Frerinith… is not).
Of course, it’s much too big, and it slips down over his eyes. But try telling him that and he’ll attack your knees.
Whispers of course he would never get one (unless Thorin jokingly gave him one, lol) but if you /had/ to make a Dark Name for Bilbo, what would that name be? Feel free to take this as seriously as you wish ofc. I am totally up for Bilbo being called Sassmaster tbh.
LMAO what’s khuzdul for Sassmaster…? XD
Well, I do like that the Hobbits have their own language… it’s not a secret language like Khuzdul, but they have one! Not that it sees much use, mind.
Bilbo’s name, in the hobbit-tongue, is in fact Bilba Labingi.
(Frodo’s is Maura Labingi, Merry is Kalimac Brandagamba, Sam is
Banazîr Galpsi and Pippin is Razanur Tûk!)
A dark-name for Bilbs, though… arrrrrgh, this is a tricky one. Okay, I think I have something…
ararrakidazbur – The Secret Diamond
This would refer to both Bilbo’s rather unexpected heroism and bravery, his brilliant, blazingly bright mind, and his secretiveness (EXCESSIVE SECRECY HELLO). It could also be seen as a reference to his rather… cutting wit (like a diamond, hee!) and his spirit.
dazbur: containing diamond (shape)* (*diamond (stone))
ararraki: continue to keep secret / to keep secret excessively
Hi! I just wanted to ask, since you’ve done a lot on dwarven aging, what do you think about hobbit aging?
Hey there! Lovely to hear from you!
Luckily, there’s HEAPS of info here. Tolkien loved his fussy little Hobbitses, and gave them plenty of attention (unlike Dwarves, I am not bitter I am bitter). So all this here? Is canon.
Hobbits age slowly, in comparison to Men. They come of age at 33 years old.
The period of their twenties is a wild and heady, irresponsible sort of time, known as the ‘tweens.’
For reference, during LOTR? Pippin is 29. (Yes, he’s not even an adult!!!) Frodo was meant to be a particularly rambunctious tween, who loved to steal Farmer Maggot’s mushrooms.
50 is literally their middle-age, as the average Hobbit’s lifespan is around 100 years old.
Bilbo is a VERY exceptional hobbit. He says at one point that his aim is to live longer than the Old Took, his grandfather Gerontius, who made it to 130 – and thanks to the Ring (and probably his own innate stubbornness) he made it to 131, before leaving for Aman where he would have eventually passed away.
There are two types of LotR fans
Those who have not read the Silmarillion and think Frodo is getting on that boat to live forever, and those who have read the Silmarillion and know that he’s off to die.
“[In the West] you would but wither and grow weary the sooner, as moths in a light too strong and steadfast.”
In some ways you could consider a mortal sailing into the West to be a form of self-euthanasia
Frodo was probably dead by the time Sam got there and that makes me cru
I tend to think the primary purpose of being in the Tolkien fandom is just to remind each other of the tragic beauty of everything in Middle-earth and cry
I can accept that mortals die in the West, but I will NEVER believe that Frodo didn’t get to see Sam again, and I honestly don’t think that’s what Tolkien intended either.










