I was only just talking about this! linddzz this is all your fault đ
So, these are only my thoughts, and they do not stomp on or contradict anybody elseâs headcanons when it comes to these characters, not at all! Thank you for asking for them, Nonnie!
Okay, well, we have Slytherin!Thorin, without a doubt. Loyal to family, willing to go to extremes to achieve an end, etc etc. Go read this post for lots of reasons! I like it so much.
Dwalin is the most Puff of Hufflepuffs to ever Puff. He and Thorin make the dynamic Slytherin-Hufflepuff duo.Â
Balin I consider a Ravenclaw, but with a bit of a Slytherin streak. Heâs sly when he needs to be, after allâŚÂ
Gloin – Gryffindor. SO Gryffindor. OUTRAGEOUSLYÂ Gryffindor.
Oin – Ravenclaw. Signs and herbs and healing ahoy!
Dori – Hufflepuff. His brothers are basically everything to him, after all.
Nori – Slytherin. Câmon. Cunning and sneaky? Yeah.Â
Ori – Ravenclaw⌠with a giant-sized Gryffindor streak a la Neville Longbottom.
Fili – Hufflepuff. âI belong with my brother!â
Kili – Gryffindor. Reckless? Yeah, totally Gryffindor.
Bofur – Hufflepuff! Heâs not all that brave, after all. But he works hard (and plays hard!) and sticks by his friends.
Bifur – I think Bifur is a Ravenclaw, despite the whole beserker rage thing. Look at the way he touches that little eagle-puppet. I can imagine him making clever and cunning little things, ancient words spilling from his lips.
Bombur – Hufflepuff as well, though he has a Gryffindor side nearly as big as his appetite đ
Bilbo – I was torn on Bilbo for a while. He could fit in any of the houses with a bit of wriggling. He is cunning and sneaky and secretive, he is clever and loves book-learning and knowledge, he values adventure and learns to be brave (in a pinch), and he is loyal, true and kind. But I have eventually settled on Gryffindor for him. Because nobody attacks a warg-riding Orc single-handedly without a healthy dollop of Gryffindor foolhardiness!
Dain – PUFF PRIDE BABY. Fair-handed, sensible, loyal and patient? PUFF.
Thranduil – Slytherin. My word yes.
Aragorn – IDK, I am in the air as to where to put Aragorn. On the one hand, he fits Gryffindor quite well. On the other, he could also be a Ravenclaw⌠(well, Book!Aragorn is a mine of knowledge after all)⌠Hmm. Perhaps he is the Hermione Granger of Middle Earth!
Gandalf – Slytherin. For obvious reasons!!!
Legolas – Gryffindor. INSANELY reckless, after all⌠and though he is smart and tremendously loyal, the Gryff in him wins out. (One word – OLIPHAUNT).
Gimli –Â âFaithless is he who says farewell when the road darkensâ should really replace the Hufflepuff slogan, tbh.
Boromir – Gryffindor⌠though there is also an argument to be made for Slytherin there!Â
Pippin – Here we have the anti-Neville, the Gryffindor who is foolhardy and overcompensating because he isnât sure he fits in. He finds his place eventually!
Merry – Hufflepuff. Heâs scared a lot, but all he wants to do is fight for his friends.Â
Frodo – Ravenclaw. Frodo is learned. He speaks three languages, he writes his books, he uses and seeks out knowledge that he can apply. He is also clever as heck with words: the whole of âThe Window on the Westâ proves that!Â
Sam – Hufflepuff, the quintessential Hufflepuff.Â
Eowyn – Slytherin (I know itâs not the usual place to sort her⌠but she is ambitious!! And SNEAKY. And so incredibly loyal to Theoden, just⌠ARGH.)
Eomer – Gryffindor yo.
Faramir – Ravenclaw.
âI do not love the bright sword for its sharpness, nor the arrow for its swiftness, nor the warrior for his glory. I love only that which they defend.â He is wise as heck. Called a âwizardâs petâ and known for disappearing in the archives⌠yeah. Ravenclawwww.Â
Theoden – Gryffindor.
Arwen – Hufflepuff. Oh, Arwen darling.Â
Galadriel – SLYTHERIN OH MY GOD. Artanis, Nerwen, the Elf who wanted more than the Gardens of Valinor and crossed the grinding ice to get it, who followed her family into exile, who had so much pride?
âŚ
(Now for some Sansukh-characters!)
Frerin – PUFF PUFF PUFF PUFF
Dis – Slytherin.Â
Thrain – Gryffindor.
Fris – Ravenclaw
Hrera – Slytherin
Thror – Gryffindor (what the hell, Thror, why are you off to Moria alone, are you completely nuts)
Loni – Slytherin.Â
Frar – Hufflepuff
Jeri – Ravenclaw. Yes, Jeri has dyscalculia, but is also an amazing tactical thinker. Not all intelligence is book-smarts đ
Baris – Hufflepuff. She looks after everybody else.
Gimizh – SLYTHERIN. OH MY GOD YES.
Wee Thorin – Hufflepuff.
Frerinith – Gryffindor
Balinith – Ravenclaw
Laerophen – Ravenclaw
Laindawar – Slytherin
Thira – Ravenclaw.Â
Thorin Stonehelm – Oh baby. Here is a Gryffindor who has the most EPIC case of Neville-Longbottomitis ever. He has always hesitated when it comes to putting himself forward, always hovered in the orbit of all these titans of recent history. Nowadays, heâs finally, finally coming into his own at last.
Bomfris – Slytherin. She has a powerful urge to prove herself, that girl! And she is ambitious (though it is for recognition, not for power) and she is shockingly protective of those she loves. Â
âŚ
Bonus round: Elrond is absolutely a Ravenclaw, to my mind.

EDIT: goddamn it, I forgot people!!! I knew I would, gah. Sorry sorry sorry. Fixed!
